Insulin Resistance With a Normal A1c? What Your Labs Are Missing
Yes, you can have insulin resistance with a normal A1c. Your A1c and fasting glucose measure your blood sugar. They do not measure how hard your body is working to keep it there. In the early years, your pancreas makes extra insulin to hold your blood sugar in range. Your glucose looks normal while your insulin runs high. A fasting insulin test, or a glucose and insulin test after a meal, can show this years before your A1c moves.
What insulin resistance is
Insulin is the hormone that moves sugar out of your blood and into your cells, where you use it for energy. When your cells stop responding well to insulin, your pancreas makes more of it to get the same job done. That is insulin resistance.
High insulin does more than move sugar. It tells your body to store fat, especially around your middle. It makes it harder for you to burn stored fat between meals. It can also raise androgens in women and affect how your ovaries work.
Why your A1c can look normal
Your A1c shows your average blood sugar over the last two to three months. Your fasting glucose shows your blood sugar on one morning. Both stay in range as long as your pancreas can keep up.
In the Whitehall II study, researchers followed more than 6,500 adults for over a decade. In the people whose blood sugar later climbed, insulin sensitivity was already falling years earlier, while fasting glucose stayed fairly flat until the last few years (Tabák et al., 2009, The Lancet).
That means a normal A1c tells you your pancreas is still keeping up. It does not tell you how much insulin it takes to do it.
Signs your insulin may be running high
You may have high insulin with normal blood sugar if you notice:
- Weight gain around your belly, even when you eat less
- An energy crash or sleepiness after meals, especially after carbs
- Strong cravings for sugar or bread, or feeling hungry soon after you eat
- Feeling shaky, irritable or lightheaded when you go too long without food
- Skin tags on your neck or under your arms
- Darker, velvety skin on the back of your neck, armpits or groin
- Irregular cycles, acne on your jawline or extra facial hair
- High triglycerides or low HDL on your lipid panel
If you crash after eating, read Why Am I So Tired After Eating?. If you get shaky between meals, read Why Do I Get Shaky When I'm Hungry?.
The deficiency and toxicity side
In Diana's approach, insulin resistance usually comes from two things: something your body is missing, and something your body is carrying. Your terrain, meaning your sleep, stress, movement and gut, decides how much either one affects you.
Deficiency
- Magnesium. Your cells need magnesium to respond to insulin. Low magnesium is common and does not show up well on a standard serum test.
- Chromium. Chromium helps insulin do its job at the cell.
- Vitamin D. Low vitamin D is linked to poorer insulin sensitivity.
- Protein and fiber. Without enough of either at meals, your blood sugar rises faster and your body needs more insulin.
- Muscle. Your muscles are where most of the sugar from a meal goes. Less muscle means fewer places to put it.
- Sleep. Even a few nights of short sleep can lower your insulin sensitivity.
Test before you add supplements. Your results decide what comes first.
Toxicity
- Ongoing stress. Cortisol raises your blood sugar, and your body answers with more insulin. If you wake up wired or anxious, read Why Do I Wake Up With Anxiety?.
- Environmental chemicals. Some plastics, pesticides and other chemicals are stored in your fat and can interfere with how your cells respond to insulin.
- Mold. Mold exposure adds to your inflammation load and can affect your blood sugar control.
- Gut imbalance. Your gut flora affects how you handle sugar and how much inflammation you carry.
- Ultra-processed food and sugary drinks. These spike your blood sugar fast and keep your insulin high through the day.
- Alcohol. Alcohol puts extra load on your liver, and your liver plays a big part in blood sugar control.
Which labs to ask for
Ask for more than an A1c and a fasting glucose. These show you how your body handles sugar:
- Fasting insulin. Drawn in the morning before you eat. Lab reference ranges for insulin are wide, so ask your practitioner how your number compares with an optimal range.
- HOMA-IR. This is a score worked out from your fasting glucose and fasting insulin. It was first described by Matthews and colleagues as a way to estimate insulin resistance from one blood draw (Matthews et al., 1985, Diabetologia). A higher score means your body is working harder to keep your blood sugar in range.
- A glucose and insulin test after a sugar drink or a meal. Checking insulin at one and two hours can show high insulin that a fasting test misses.
- A lipid panel. High triglycerides and low HDL often travel with high insulin. Ask about your triglyceride to HDL ratio.
- A full thyroid panel. Slow thyroid function also slows how you use sugar. Ask for TSH, free T4, free T3, reverse T3 and thyroid antibodies.
- Vitamin D, RBC magnesium and ferritin.
You can order many of these through the DMD lab menu.
What you can do now
- Get your fasting insulin tested. This is the number most people never see.
- Eat protein at every meal. Aim to start each meal with protein and vegetables, then eat your starch last.
- Move after you eat. A 10 to 15 minute walk after meals helps your muscles take up sugar with less insulin.
- Build muscle. Strength training two to three times a week gives your body more places to store sugar.
- Cut out sugary drinks and juice. These raise your blood sugar faster than almost anything else.
- Protect your sleep. Aim for seven to nine hours, in a dark room, at the same time each night.
- Lower your chemical load. Store and heat food in glass, choose fragrance-free products and filter your water.
If you take any medication for your blood sugar, keep taking it as prescribed. Any change happens only with your prescribing practitioner's supervision.
Insulin sensitivity often improves once your minerals, sleep, stress and muscle are supported. To see how Diana works with energy and metabolism, visit the energy page.
Find out where to start
Not sure whether your energy and weight changes come from your insulin, your thyroid or your stress hormones? Take the free health quiz to see which system needs attention first, or book a free 15-minute call with Diana to talk through your symptoms and labs.
These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This information is educational and is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease, nor to substitute for care from a licensed medical provider. Diana Drake is a Board Certified Traditional Naturopath, not a licensed medical doctor, and does not diagnose disease or prescribe medication.
